The Best Non-Candy Easter Basket Stuffers (Handmade & Kept All Year)

Chocolate melts, jelly beans vanish by Sunday night — but a handmade plush bunny? That one gets clipped to a backpack and loved all year. If you’re hunting for non-candy Easter basket stuffers for Easter 2027 (Sunday, March 28) that feel thoughtful — and survive past breakfast — here are our favourites.

Why non-candy Easter gifts win

Non-candy basket fillers are having a moment — parents want less sugar, and kids (and adults) love something they can actually keep. Handmade plush keychains hit the sweet spot: small enough for any basket, cute enough to show off, and collectible enough that most people don’t stop at one.

The best non-candy Easter basket stuffers for 2027

1. Handmade plush bunny keychains

Our signature plush bunny keychains arrive in their own collector’s tin — basket-ready with no wrapping. Each has a name and a personality, from Snugglylulu to Luckylulu.

2. Pocket-sized mini bunnies

The Spotted Mini-Bunny keychains are perfect for smaller baskets and little hands.

3. Capybaras & teddies for non-bunny fans

Not everyone wants a bunny — our capybara keychains and teddy keychains are just as huggable and collectible.

4. A full-size cuddle bunny for the big surprise

For the centrepiece of the basket, the XL Bunny Plush arrives in a keepsake gift box.

How to choose the right Easter gift

• For little kids: mini bunnies and soft plush.
• For teens: a bag-charm keychain they’ll actually clip on.
• For her / for adults: a keepsake keychain in its tin, or a cuddle-size plush.

Frequently asked questions

What are good non-candy Easter basket stuffers? Handmade plush keychains, mini bunnies, and small collectible toys — cute, keepable, and kinder on the sugar than chocolate.

What’s the best Easter gift for adults? A soft bunny keychain in a keepsake tin, or a full-size cuddle bunny — a sweet handmade alternative to candy.

When is Easter 2027? Easter Sunday is March 28, 2027 — order a week or two ahead so your baskets arrive in time.

Do these come ready for the basket? Yes — every BunnyLulu arrives in its own designed tin or gift box, so there’s no wrapping needed.

Ready to build your basket? Browse the full Easter Gifts collection.